User:Samanem: Difference between revisions

From Librivox wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Content deleted Content added
Samanem (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Samanem (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 12: Line 12:
:* '''Compression'''
:* '''Compression'''
:* '''Amplification'''
:* '''Amplification'''
:* '''Leveller'''
I'll explain what the settings mean and what to set them on in typical situations, and try to give a rough guide to when to use each of them, and when its probably best not to use them. Keep in mind many of these Effects are done to the ear of the listener, and therefore are subjective - i.e. my ear may not agree with your ear.
I'll explain what the settings mean and what to set them on in typical situations, and try to give a rough guide to when to use each of them, and when its probably best not to use them. Keep in mind many of these Effects are done to the ear of the listener, and therefore are subjective - i.e. my ear may not agree with your ear.


Line 25: Line 26:
The microphone is sometimes an obstacle. Without mandating a certain type of microphone, it can reasonably be stated that the better the microphone, the better you are going to sound, and <i>the easier it will be to sound good.</i>
The microphone is sometimes an obstacle. Without mandating a certain type of microphone, it can reasonably be stated that the better the microphone, the better you are going to sound, and <i>the easier it will be to sound good.</i>


The microphone's job is to capture the sounds you make. Your job is to keep it from capturing the sound that are made by other things around you. The good news is, the more you give the mic to capture with your voice, the less interested the mic will be in the other stuff. Basically the more signal you give you mic with you voice, the less noise is picked up. One very easy way to avoid picking up noise!


Some mics are more sensitive to others, and some are more directional in how they capture sound. That means some will capture sounds that come mostly just in front of the mic, while others will cpature sounds from all-around the mic. When you're buying a mic for recording voice, its best to try to get a mic that is directional, so it will not be picking up sounds from behind the mic while you're talking into it.


One useful way to categorize mics is in terms of how they deliver their signal to the computer. We can group these as:
== '''Input Volume''' ==
:* '''Built-in Mics''' (Often seen in laptop computers)
:* '''Analog Mics''' (Round plugs)
:* '''USB Mics''' (Flat broad plugs)


It is almost always true that there are good and bad in every category, but that rule is, well, just not very true in this case. For recording voice, it is very difficult to achieve the kind of volume levels we need while at the same time avoiding noise with the built-in mics. This is also true of many analog mics, although there are exceptions here. There are some analog headset mics that are being used that can achieve good results, but they require lots of practice, careful placement and dutiful attention to how the capturing membrane is positioned relative to the mouth while you're speaking.


In many cases these analog mics end up with noise in the recording that comes through the system, related to the computer's sound card and the analog-to-digital converter as the analog signal is processed and delivered into digital form. We have worked with many of these mics and been unable to get this noise down to happy levels, and at that point thwe only real solution is to upgrade to a USB mic.
xxx


USB mics are the best category, generally speaking. If you were to purchase a new mic, it would be best to seek out one of these, since they will have a much better chance of producing a good result with a minimum of system noise. Many of these types of mics are self contained, but this category can see the quality and price go up considerably, and have the mic plug into various processing boxes before the signal comes into the computer. At the starter level, however, there are many on the market that are plug 'n play, and produce excellent results for our purposes.


== '''Input Volume''' ==


The most common problem new user have is a low input volume with their recordings. When we work with people and their 1-Minute Tests, we often have to go back and forth several times before people are convinced that they truly do need to turn up their input volume levels all the way, and in every area possible.
== '''Noise''' ==




xxx


== '''Noise''' ==

have a significant amount of noise in the background. Some of this will be reduced if you increase your input volume, but you also need to work on reducing the level of noise, if possible. If you're on a laptop, obviously this is much easier to do, whereas if you're stuck at your PC, this gets harder.
====Optimizing Your Environment====
====Optimizing Your Environment====


Please investigate where you are doing your recording and see if you have a large electrical source nearby, appliances, a tangle of large wires, large wires crossing at odd angles (i.e. non right-angles), any devices plugged in that you don't need absolutely such as extra hard drives, the electrical plugs for your PC sound system, fish tank, etc. etc. Also anything like an Air-Conditioning unit running that you might not think about right off. Basically anything that could directly or indirectly cause the noise.
xxx

If you're on a laptop, try taking the laptop to another location. This can help get away from electrical interference but can also help with acoustics (try a closet full of soft clothes).

you sound like you're recording in a room with bare walls, and we are picking up a lot of echo off the walls, and extra noise that is magnified because of bouncing off all those walls.

You could improve your sound tremendously, I would wager, if you could move to a location that has buffereing around you, such as in a closet with clothes around, or a corner of a room with bookshelves around. Even piles of objects lining the walls can break up the ability of the sound to bounce off and head back to the mic.

If you're on a laptop, obviously this is much easier to do, whereas if you're stuck at your PC, this gets harder. But even so, at a PC you can pile things around or put a bookshelf on the bare wall here and there that will improve the sound remarkably. The mic will pick up more of your voice and less of the noise, and you'll sound more close and immediate, and you'll also be able to do more processing like amplification, Noise Removal, etc. to your files and make them sound even better.


====Other Types of Noise====
====Other Types of Noise====


You can also try recording on battery power, since sometimes the charging of the battery when plugged in can cause an electrical noise (I don't have this problem but some do). I plotted your sound spectrum but didn't see a significant hum that would indicated that your noise is an electrical power supply, but it could be indirectly.
xxx

It's also possible this noise is just due to your mic and your system (what kind of mic are you using?), but if so its even more important to minimize other sources of noise so you can optimize your sound.




Line 64: Line 85:
====Noise Removal====
====Noise Removal====


it's good to leave a little bit of noise so the ear doesn't hear complete silence in betweene the words - it sounds too weird that way.
xxx

If you're using Audacity, here's a tutorial on how to do it, and I would suggest settings like 12/200/0.1 for the three numbers that you can change, which are probably lighter than the ones you've used in the past. It's also better to do light settings twice than to use heavy settings once, as far as it affecting the voice:

http://wiki.librivox.org/index.php/Noisecleaning_With_Pics

Make sure you leave several seconds of quiet at the end so you can select that as your "Noise" Profile for use with the Noise Removal. You wouldn't want to do it twice with heavier settings, and even once with heavier settings can cause distortion.

Here's a more detailed primer on using Noise Removal:

http://wiki.librivox.org/index.php/Detailed_Audacity_Noise_Removal

but basically the first number is how much volume you want the noise reduced by (lower is by less volume and will leave more noise, higher number will remove more noise but might distort voice), the second is how broad a "brush" you want the program to use in deciding what is noise (i.e. a higher number would be better for more complex sounds, a lower one for simple sounds), and the third relates to how quickly you want the noise to drop off toward silence after your word has ended (a 0.0 will chop off immediately after the word has ended and might sound chopped off).

I usually use 12/200 and 0.0, but I have very little noise in my recordings. Some people use hefiter numbers in the first two, but if you do, it'll sound chopped off unless you give it a little space on the last number, like a 0.1 or 0.15.

In the end you have to find what works best or your voice and your setup and your recordings.
[[Image:Noise_Waveform.jpg|thumb|alt=A waveform in Audacity showing significant noise present.|Waveform with significant noise]]


====Amplification====
====Amplification====
Line 75: Line 113:




Our format needs to be in mp3, mono, 44,100Hz, 16-bit, 128kbps and usually louder than most people think! :D This is so all our files can be handled on the far end uniformly. The links will also explain how to upload here at Librivox. People here are very helpful and friendly, so don't be afraid to ask any questions you have along the way.
xxx

But the first step will be to upload a [b]1-Minute Test Recording[/b] for each reader: [url=http://wiki.librivox.org/index.php/1-Minute_Test]1-Minute Test[/url] The test is uploaded and then the url is posted as a new topic thread in the Listeners Wanted Forum. Instructions are in the link.

This test is of course not for any kind of audition purposes, just to make sure it fits our format technically and that your levels are okay. Once you complete this step, and your test is marked [OK], let me know in this thread and I can get you signed up for reading a section! Let me know if you have any questions or problems.

Revision as of 00:37, 9 June 2011

For New Members at Librivox

Introduction

This page is dedicated to helping new users begin their journey at Librivox. We will mainly be concerned with how to get up to speed with recording for Librivox, and making it as easy as possible. We will discuss microphone selection and placement, as well as the use of pop screens and other methods for cleaning up the capture of your voice into your microphone. We'll talk about the input volume levels of your recordings and how to increase them, which is a common problem among new readers. We'll help you understand noise and why it appears on your recordings, where it comes from, and how to minimize it so that your voice is maximized relative to the noise. We'll touch on recognizing some different types of noise, such as fans vs. electrical hums and some easy ways to avoid recording them.

We'll also go through Audacity and some of the common Effects that are used, such as:

  • Noise Removal
  • Normalization
  • Compression
  • Amplification
  • Leveller

I'll explain what the settings mean and what to set them on in typical situations, and try to give a rough guide to when to use each of them, and when its probably best not to use them. Keep in mind many of these Effects are done to the ear of the listener, and therefore are subjective - i.e. my ear may not agree with your ear.

Once we've gone through these things, we've have you ready to record and submit your 1-Minute Test. I'll show you how to do it, where to upload it, what username and password to use, and where and how to post the url to get comments. When you've gotten your 1-Minute Test OK'd, you'll be ready to enter the Public Domain, and I'll show you where to go to get started with recording - where to go to find things to record, and what your options are for choosing works in the Public Domain.

Once you're done with these steps, you will be Grade A Certified and 100% Qualified as a Librivox reader, and should be able to produce quality recordings that will endure in the Digital Cloud forever and bring pleasure and happiness to many listeners around the world!


Microphone Selection

The microphone is sometimes an obstacle. Without mandating a certain type of microphone, it can reasonably be stated that the better the microphone, the better you are going to sound, and the easier it will be to sound good.

The microphone's job is to capture the sounds you make. Your job is to keep it from capturing the sound that are made by other things around you. The good news is, the more you give the mic to capture with your voice, the less interested the mic will be in the other stuff. Basically the more signal you give you mic with you voice, the less noise is picked up. One very easy way to avoid picking up noise!

Some mics are more sensitive to others, and some are more directional in how they capture sound. That means some will capture sounds that come mostly just in front of the mic, while others will cpature sounds from all-around the mic. When you're buying a mic for recording voice, its best to try to get a mic that is directional, so it will not be picking up sounds from behind the mic while you're talking into it.

One useful way to categorize mics is in terms of how they deliver their signal to the computer. We can group these as:

  • Built-in Mics (Often seen in laptop computers)
  • Analog Mics (Round plugs)
  • USB Mics (Flat broad plugs)

It is almost always true that there are good and bad in every category, but that rule is, well, just not very true in this case. For recording voice, it is very difficult to achieve the kind of volume levels we need while at the same time avoiding noise with the built-in mics. This is also true of many analog mics, although there are exceptions here. There are some analog headset mics that are being used that can achieve good results, but they require lots of practice, careful placement and dutiful attention to how the capturing membrane is positioned relative to the mouth while you're speaking.

In many cases these analog mics end up with noise in the recording that comes through the system, related to the computer's sound card and the analog-to-digital converter as the analog signal is processed and delivered into digital form. We have worked with many of these mics and been unable to get this noise down to happy levels, and at that point thwe only real solution is to upgrade to a USB mic.

USB mics are the best category, generally speaking. If you were to purchase a new mic, it would be best to seek out one of these, since they will have a much better chance of producing a good result with a minimum of system noise. Many of these types of mics are self contained, but this category can see the quality and price go up considerably, and have the mic plug into various processing boxes before the signal comes into the computer. At the starter level, however, there are many on the market that are plug 'n play, and produce excellent results for our purposes.

Input Volume

The most common problem new user have is a low input volume with their recordings. When we work with people and their 1-Minute Tests, we often have to go back and forth several times before people are convinced that they truly do need to turn up their input volume levels all the way, and in every area possible.


Noise

have a significant amount of noise in the background. Some of this will be reduced if you increase your input volume, but you also need to work on reducing the level of noise, if possible. If you're on a laptop, obviously this is much easier to do, whereas if you're stuck at your PC, this gets harder.

Optimizing Your Environment

Please investigate where you are doing your recording and see if you have a large electrical source nearby, appliances, a tangle of large wires, large wires crossing at odd angles (i.e. non right-angles), any devices plugged in that you don't need absolutely such as extra hard drives, the electrical plugs for your PC sound system, fish tank, etc. etc. Also anything like an Air-Conditioning unit running that you might not think about right off. Basically anything that could directly or indirectly cause the noise.

If you're on a laptop, try taking the laptop to another location. This can help get away from electrical interference but can also help with acoustics (try a closet full of soft clothes).

you sound like you're recording in a room with bare walls, and we are picking up a lot of echo off the walls, and extra noise that is magnified because of bouncing off all those walls.  

You could improve your sound tremendously, I would wager, if you could move to a location that has buffereing around you, such as in a closet with clothes around, or a corner of a room with bookshelves around. Even piles of objects lining the walls can break up the ability of the sound to bounce off and head back to the mic.

If you're on a laptop, obviously this is much easier to do, whereas if you're stuck at your PC, this gets harder. But even so, at a PC you can pile things around or put a bookshelf on the bare wall here and there that will improve the sound remarkably. The mic will pick up more of your voice and less of the noise, and you'll sound more close and immediate, and you'll also be able to do more processing like amplification, Noise Removal, etc. to your files and make them sound even better.

Other Types of Noise

You can also try recording on battery power, since sometimes the charging of the battery when plugged in can cause an electrical noise (I don't have this problem but some do). I plotted your sound spectrum but didn't see a significant hum that would indicated that your noise is an electrical power supply, but it could be indirectly.

It's also possible this noise is just due to your mic and your system (what kind of mic are you using?), but if so its even more important to minimize other sources of noise so you can optimize your sound.


Using Audacity

xxx

Normalization

xxx

Compression

xxx

Noise Removal

it's good to leave a little bit of noise so the ear doesn't hear complete silence in betweene the words - it sounds too weird that way.

If you're using Audacity, here's a tutorial on how to do it, and I would suggest settings like 12/200/0.1 for the three numbers that you can change, which are probably lighter than the ones you've used in the past. It's also better to do light settings twice than to use heavy settings once, as far as it affecting the voice:

http://wiki.librivox.org/index.php/Noisecleaning_With_Pics

Make sure you leave several seconds of quiet at the end so you can select that as your "Noise" Profile for use with the Noise Removal. You wouldn't want to do it twice with heavier settings, and even once with heavier settings can cause distortion.

Here's a more detailed primer on using Noise Removal:

http://wiki.librivox.org/index.php/Detailed_Audacity_Noise_Removal

but basically the first number is how much volume you want the noise reduced by (lower is by less volume and will leave more noise, higher number will remove more noise but might distort voice), the second is how broad a "brush" you want the program to use in deciding what is noise (i.e. a higher number would be better for more complex sounds, a lower one for simple sounds), and the third relates to how quickly you want the noise to drop off toward silence after your word has ended (a 0.0 will chop off immediately after the word has ended and might sound chopped off).

I usually use 12/200 and 0.0, but I have very little noise in my recordings. Some people use hefiter numbers in the first two, but if you do, it'll sound chopped off unless you give it a little space on the last number, like a 0.1 or 0.15.

In the end you have to find what works best or your voice and your setup and your recordings.

A waveform in Audacity showing significant noise present.
Waveform with significant noise

Amplification

xxx


The 1-Minute Test

Our format needs to be in mp3, mono, 44,100Hz, 16-bit, 128kbps and usually louder than most people think! :D This is so all our files can be handled on the far end uniformly. The links will also explain how to upload here at Librivox. People here are very helpful and friendly, so don't be afraid to ask any questions you have along the way.

But the first step will be to upload a [b]1-Minute Test Recording[/b] for each reader: [url=http://wiki.librivox.org/index.php/1-Minute_Test]1-Minute Test[/url] The test is uploaded and then the url is posted as a new topic thread in the Listeners Wanted Forum. Instructions are in the link.

This test is of course not for any kind of audition purposes, just to make sure it fits our format technically and that your levels are okay. Once you complete this step, and your test is marked [OK], let me know in this thread and I can get you signed up for reading a section! Let me know if you have any questions or problems.