Software We Use: Difference between revisions

From Librivox wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Content deleted Content added
Jc (talk | contribs)
New page: This page lists software used or recommended by our volunteers. Here you will find programs to record, edit, or playback audio. There are also encoders, ID3 tag editors, and more. Many of ...
 
→‎Others: Updated installation and use instructions are on the page itself
 
(28 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:
Please notice this table is based on what LibriVox volunteers know about these programs, so it is certainly incomplete and, in part, based on opinion.
Please notice this table is based on what LibriVox volunteers know about these programs, so it is certainly incomplete and, in part, based on opinion.


===Chart Legend ===
{| border=1 cellspacing=0
<b>Feature list</b> <br/>
<i>Mac</i> = Apple Macintosh. <br/>
<i>Win</i> = MS Windows. <br/>
<i>Lin</i> = Linux <br/>
<i>Rec.</i> = program can record <br/>
<i>Playbk</i> = program can play back <br/>
<i>MP3</i> = program can encode to MP3 format. <br/>
<i>ID3</i> = program is or has an ID3 tag editor. <br/>
<i>rip</i> = program can extract, or rip, tracks from audio CDs. <br/>
<i>burn</i> = program can write, or burn, audio CDs. <br/>

<b>Feature indicators</b> <br/>
<i>Y</i> = feature is available. <br/>
- = feature available in test/experimental version. <br/>
- = feature not available. <br/>
Under cost, the number of dollar signs ('$') indicates the relative price, <i>0</i> = free, and <i>0$</i> = comes in both free and pay versions (pay versions have more features).

Under playback, most letters indicate formats: <br/>
<i>W</i> = Wave, <i>A</i> = AAIF, <i>M</i> = MP3, <i>C</i> = audio CDs, <i>Y</i> = too many to list.

Under MP3, <i>E</i> = with user-installed encoder (straightforward to do).

A letter in <b>bold face</b> indicates the program excels at or is primarily designed to do that task (but that doesn't mean other programs with the same feature which are not bold are bad at that task).

A blank cell generally means "we don't know".

===Recording===
{| style="border-collapse:collapse" border=1 cellspacing=0
|-style="background:#ccddff" align="center"
|-style="background:#ccddff" align="center"
! || || Mac || Win || Linux || Cost || Record || Edit || Playback || MP3 || ID3 || rip || burn || Notes
! || Mac || Win || Lin || Cost || Rec. || Edit || Playbk || MP3 || ID3 || rip || burn || Notes
|-
|rowspan="11" | R<br>E<br>C<br>O<br>R<br>D<br>I <br>N<br>G
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
|[http://audacity.sourceforge.net/ Audacity] || Y|| Y|| Y|| 0|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| WA|| E|| Y|| || || align="left"| <b>free</b> - A pretty good free audio recording/editing software. Has a number of built in plugins and enhancements are available for free as well. LibriVox's [[Audacity FAQ]].
|[http://audacity.sourceforge.net/ Audacity] || Y|| Y|| Y|| 0|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| WA|| E|| Y|| || || align="left"| <b>free</b> - Pretty good software. Built-in free plugins, enhancements available. [[Audacity FAQ]].
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|[http://www.adobe.com/products/audition/main.html Adobe Audition 2.0] ||n||<b>Y</b>|| n|| $$|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| Y|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Adobe purchased Cool Edit Pro, and has enhanced it. A very good multitrack editing/recording application and the newest version (2.0) has a lot of great features. Comes with a large number of effects and plugins included.
|[http://www.adobe.com/products/audition/main.html Adobe Audition 3] ||-||<b>Y</b>|| -|| $$|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>|| Y|| <b>Y</b>|| <b>Y</b>||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Adobe purchased and enhanced Cool Edit Pro. Many effects & plugins included. <br/> Very good, multitrack editing/recording, lot of great features.
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
|[http://www.bias-inc.com/products/peakPro5/ Bias Peak] || Y ||n ||n || $$ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || || || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Another professional sound/editing package. Peak is limited to one stereo track, but is significantly less expensive than Digital Performer.
|[http://www.bias-inc.com/products/peakPro5/ Bias Peak] || Y ||- ||- || $$ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || || || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Professional sound/editing package. Limited to single stereo track.
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|Cool Edit ||n || Y ||n|| 0 ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || WC || Y || || || n||align="left"|(not available commercially) - Cool Edit 2000 and Cool Edit Pro are very good editing and recording programs. The Cool Edit noise reduction filter works especially well.
|Cool Edit ||- || Y ||-|| 0 ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || WC || Y || || || -||align="left"|(not available commercially) - Very good program, noise reduction filter works especially well.
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
|Exact Audio Copy ||n || Y ||n || 0 || Y || Y || WC || E || Y ||'''Y''' || Y ||
|[http://www.apple.com/ilife/garageband/ GarageBand] || Y ||- ||- ||0$ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || A
|colspan="4"|Autosends AAIF <br/> output to iTunes || align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Included with new Mac computer, or available when you buy Apple iLife. Difficult to export an MP3 that is both mono AND 128 kbps; w do not yet know the exact settings to use to do this.<br/> [[GarageBand | Librivox's GarageBand FAQ ]].
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|[http://www.apple.com/ilife/garageband/ GarageBand] || Y ||n ||n ||0$ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || A
| [http://www.motu.com/products/software/dp/ MOTU] || Y ||- ||- || $$$ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || || || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Very expensive, professional sound editing/recording software. <br/>
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|colspan="4"|Autosends AAIF output to iTunes || align="left"|<b>pay</b> - While technically not free, it is included with the purchase of a new Macintosh Computer. Otherwise, it is available when you buy Apple iLife. LibriVox's [[GarageBand | FAQ and User Guide]] for GarageBand.
|[https://www.ocenaudio.com/ ocenaudio] ||Y ||Y ||Y || 0 ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || Y || Y || || ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - similar to Twisted Wave, but also has Punch and Roll
|- align="center"
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
| [http://www.motu.com/products/software/dp/ MOTU] || Y ||n ||n || $$$ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || || || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - A very expensive, professional sound editing/recording software. This is generally more than anyone recording for LibriVox will need, but some volunteers have access to professional recording studios.
|[https://www.reaper.fm/index.php Reaper] ||Y ||Y ||X || $ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || Y || || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - $60 thru version 6.99. Pretty big learning curve and way more than is needed for Librivox.
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|[http://www.sonymediasoftware.com/products/soundforgefamily.asp Sound Forge] ||- || Y ||- || $ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || || || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Good Windows application. Single stereo track, usually enough for LibriVox recording.
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|[http://www.sonymediasoftware.com/products/soundforgefamily.asp Sound Forge] ||n || Y ||n || $ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || || || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Another good Windows recording/editing application. It operates on a single stereo track, which is usually enough for most recording, especially LibriVox.
| [http://www.freeverse.com/soundstudio/ Sound Studio]|| Y ||- ||- || $ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || WAM || Y || Y || || ||align="left"|<b>pay </b>- Costs around $80. Extremely intuitive and easy-to-use interface for recording and editing.
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
| [http://www.freeverse.com/soundstudio/ Sound Studio]|| Y ||n ||n || $ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || WAM || n ||n|| || ||align="left"|<b>pay </b>- Costs around $80. Extremely intuitive and easy-to-use interface for recording and editing.
|[http://www.highcriteria.com/ Total Recorder] ||- || Y ||-|| $ ||'''Y''' || Y || WM || E ||- || - || -||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Inexpensive. Standard or Pro. [http://www.highcriteria.com/AddOnMain.htm Plugins], including for [http://www.highcriteria.com/AddOnAGC.htm speech recording]. <br/> Split and splice files of various formats. Evaluation copies of both versions available; pro would be better for LibriVox because of superior editing capabilities.
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|[https://twistedwave.com/ Twisted Wave] ||Y ||- ||- || $$ ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || W || Y || Y || || ||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - Mac Desktop $80, iPad & iPhone @ $10, and online with subscription $5 to $200.
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
| [http://www.nch.com.au/wavepad/ WavePad Sound Editor]|| Y || Y || Y || 0/$ || '''Y''' || '''Y''' || WAM || Y || - || || ||align="left"|<b>free/pay </b>- Free demo edition that does most things. Update to full Masters edition costs around $40.
|[http://www.highcriteria.com/ Total Recorder] ||n || Y ||n|| $ ||'''Y''' || Y || WM || E ||n || n || n||align="left"|<b>pay</b> - An inexpensive recorder in two versions, standard and pro. It also does audio editing. Plugins are [http://www.highcriteria.com/AddOnMain.htm available], including one designed for [http://www.highcriteria.com/AddOnAGC.htm speech recording]. Edit ID3 tags. Split and splice files of various formats. Evaluation copies of both versions are available; the pro version would be better for LibriVox work because of its superior editing capabilities.
|-
|}

| rowspan="5" | P<br>L<br>A<br>Y<br>B<br>A<br>C<br>K
===Playback===
{| border=1 cellspacing=0 style="border-collapse:collapse"
|-style="background:#ccddff" align="center"
! || Mac || Win || Lin || Cost || Rec. || Edit || Playbk || MP3 || ID3 || rip || burn || Notes
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
|| [http://www.apple.com/itunes/ iTunes] || Y || Y || || 0 || || ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || Y ||'''Y''' || Y ||align="left"|<b>free</b>
|| [http://www.apple.com/itunes/ iTunes] || Y || Y || || 0 || || ||'''Y''' ||'''Y''' || Y ||'''Y''' || Y ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - Playback and convert files to mp3.
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|-style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
| [http://www.songbirdnest.com/ SongBird] || p || Y || p || 0 || || ||'''Y''' || || || || ||align="left"|<b>free </b>- As of 2006 February, the versions for Linux and the Macintosh are planned, but are not yet available.
| [http://www.songbirdnest.com/ SongBird] || Y || Y || Y || 0 || || ||'''Y''' || || || || ||align="left"|<b>free </b>- Now available for both Mac and Linux.
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
|[http://www.winamp.com/ Winamp]||n || Y ||n || 0$ || n || n ||'''Y''' || ||'''Y''' || Y || Y ||align="left"|both <b>free</b> and <b>pay</b> - Play many audio and video formats; has media library manager, playlist editor, and ID3 tag editor; rip, burn, and convert between formats. Supports skins and third-party plugins.
|[http://www.winamp.com/ Winamp]||- || Y ||- || 0$ || - || - ||'''Y''' || ||'''Y''' || Y || Y ||align="left"|both <b>free</b> and <b>pay</b> - Plays many audio and video formats; has media library manager, playlist editor, and ID3 tag editor; rip, burn, and convert between formats. Supports skins and third-party plugins.
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|[http://www.microsoft.com/windows/windowsmedia/default.mspx Windows Media Player]||n || Y ||n ||(0) || || n ||'''Y''' || || || Y || ||align="left"|<b>free</b>
|[http://www.microsoft.com/windows/windowsmedia/default.mspx Windows Media Player]||- || Y ||- ||(0) || || - ||'''Y''' || || || Y || ||align="left"|<b>free</b>
|-
|}

| rowspan="4" | O<br>T<br>H<br>E<br>R<br>S
===Others===
|-align="center"
{| border=1 cellspacing=0 style="border-collapse:collapse"
| LAME || Y || Y || || 0 ||n ||n||n||'''Y''' || n || n|| n ||
|-style="background:#ccddff" align="center"
! || Mac || Win || Lin || Cost || Rec. || Edit || Playbk || MP3 || ID3 || rip || burn || Notes
|- align="center"
|[[Checker]] || Y || Y || Y || 0 || - || - || - || - || Y || - || - ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - Checks tech specs, volume, background noise, ID tags on an MP3. Uses LibriVox's standards. Ability to change ID tags.
|- align="center"
|[http://www.exactaudiocopy.de/ Exact Audio Copy] ||- || Y ||- || 0 || Y || Y || WC || E || Y ||'''Y''' || Y ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - Best CD ripper. Record & edit Wave files. Convert Wave to MP3 (with LAME). <br/> (located here because we have no experience using it to record/edit)
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
| [http://audacity.sourceforge.net/help/faq?s=install&item=lame-mp3 LAME] || Y || Y ||Y|| 0 ||- ||-||-||'''Y''' || - || -|| - ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - One of the two best MP3 encoders. Windows version is command-line, but mostly used with other programs.
| MP3Gain ||n || Y ||n || 0 || n ||n || n ||n || n || n||n||
|- align="center"
| [http://mp3splt.sourceforge.net/ MP3 Splt] ||Y||Y||Y|| 0 || - || -|| -|| - || - || - || - ||align="left"| <b>free</b> - Splits MP3 and Ogg Vorbis files without decoding. Set split points by fixed-time length, with option to adjust split points to occur in silent gaps. Use the command-line version for batch processing of multiple files. Very fast.
|- style="background:#eeeeee" align="center"
| [http://mp3gain.sourceforge.net/ MP3Gain] ||- || Y ||Y|| 0 || - ||- || - ||- || - || -||- ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - Measure the volume of multiple MP3 files. Do NOT use it to adjust the volume. Mac version does not measure the volume but only adjusts it.
|- align="center"
| [http://www.dors.de/razorlame/ RazorLame] ||- || Y ||- || 0 ||- ||- || - || E || -|| - || - ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - Graphical user interface for the LAME encoder. <br/> Encodes one or more Wave files at a time to MP3 format. Also decodes MP3 to Wave. <br/> Inserts same information into the ID3 tag of every MP3 file in the batch.
|- align="center"
| [[Measuring Volume within Audacity|ReplayGain]] ||Y || Y || Y || 0 ||- ||- || - || - || -|| - || - ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - Audacity plug-in used to measure and adjust volume. See [[Measuring Volume within Audacity|ReplayGain]] for installation and use.
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
| RazorLame ||n|| Y ||n || 0 ||n ||n || n || E || n|| n || n ||
| [https://karikarito.com/wordcount WordCount] ||Y || Y || Y || 0 ||- ||- || - || - || -|| - || - ||align="left"|<b>free</b> - Tool for checking word counts on Gutenberg texts. Counts each chapter separately.
|}
|}

Other software to edit ID3 (Windows only):
* [http://www.softpointer.com/AudioShell.htm AudioShell] - <b>free</b> - Integrates into Windows Explorer, you just pull up Properties and it gives you tabs for viewing and editing ID3 tags.
* [http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/win/39020 ID3 renamer] - <b>free</b> - Rename a large number of files based on a formula. Can be used to mass rename ID3 tags as well

Misc:
* [http://gnuwin.epfl.ch/apps/cdex/en/install/cdex_151.exe CDex] - <b>free</b> - A great tool for ripping CDs but also changing the sample rate for MP3s

== Gord's list of freeware audio tools (including a bunch of tag editors) ==
These applications were recommended on Slashdot as being free of spyware/adware ... but, of course, you have to be the final judge.

* CDex - http://cdexos.sourceforge.net/ [sourceforge.net]
* dBpowerAMP Music Converter - http://www.dbpoweramp.com/dmc.htm [dbpoweramp.com]
* Encounter 2003 - http://www.waschbusch.com/ [waschbusch.com]
* GermaniXEncoder - http://www.germanixsoft.de/ [germanixsoft.de]
* K-MP3 - http://www.katarncorp.com/ [katarncorp.com]
* KraMixer - http://www.kramware.com/ [kramware.com]
* MP3 Book Helper - http://mp3bookhelper.sourceforge.net/ [sourceforge.net]
* MP3 Tag - http://www.mp3tag.de/ [mp3tag.de]
* mp3DirectCut - http://www.rz.uni-frankfurt.de/~pesch/ [uni-frankfurt.de]
* mp3Trim - http://www.logiccell.com/~mp3trim/ [logiccell.com]
* MusicBrainz - http://musicbrainz.org/ [musicbrainz.org]
* Rarewares - http://rarewares.hydrogenaudio.org/ [hydrogenaudio.org]
* SoundEngine Free - http://www.cycleof5th.com/en/index.htm [cycleof5th.com]
* TagScanner - http://xdev.narod.ru/tagscan_e.htm [narod.ru]
* The GodFather - http://users.otenet.gr/~jtcliper/tgf/ [otenet.gr]

Latest revision as of 21:56, 26 March 2019

This page lists software used or recommended by our volunteers. Here you will find programs to record, edit, or playback audio. There are also encoders, ID3 tag editors, and more. Many of these programs do more than one of these tasks. If you know of related software that would be useful, please let us know.

Comparison Chart

Please notice this table is based on what LibriVox volunteers know about these programs, so it is certainly incomplete and, in part, based on opinion.

Chart Legend

Feature list
Mac = Apple Macintosh.
Win = MS Windows.
Lin = Linux
Rec. = program can record
Playbk = program can play back
MP3 = program can encode to MP3 format.
ID3 = program is or has an ID3 tag editor.
rip = program can extract, or rip, tracks from audio CDs.
burn = program can write, or burn, audio CDs.

Feature indicators
Y = feature is available.
- = feature available in test/experimental version.
- = feature not available.
Under cost, the number of dollar signs ('$') indicates the relative price, 0 = free, and 0$ = comes in both free and pay versions (pay versions have more features).

Under playback, most letters indicate formats:
W = Wave, A = AAIF, M = MP3, C = audio CDs, Y = too many to list.

Under MP3, E = with user-installed encoder (straightforward to do).

A letter in bold face indicates the program excels at or is primarily designed to do that task (but that doesn't mean other programs with the same feature which are not bold are bad at that task).

A blank cell generally means "we don't know".

Recording

Mac Win Lin Cost Rec. Edit Playbk MP3 ID3 rip burn Notes
Audacity Y Y Y 0 Y Y WA E Y free - Pretty good software. Built-in free plugins, enhancements available. Audacity FAQ.
Adobe Audition 3 - Y - $$ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y pay - Adobe purchased and enhanced Cool Edit Pro. Many effects & plugins included.
Very good, multitrack editing/recording, lot of great features.
Bias Peak Y - - $$ Y Y W pay - Professional sound/editing package. Limited to single stereo track.
Cool Edit - Y - 0 Y Y WC Y - (not available commercially) - Very good program, noise reduction filter works especially well.
GarageBand Y - - 0$ Y Y A Autosends AAIF
output to iTunes
pay - Included with new Mac computer, or available when you buy Apple iLife. Difficult to export an MP3 that is both mono AND 128 kbps; w do not yet know the exact settings to use to do this.
Librivox's GarageBand FAQ .
MOTU Y - - $$$ Y Y W pay - Very expensive, professional sound editing/recording software.
ocenaudio Y Y Y 0 Y Y W Y Y free - similar to Twisted Wave, but also has Punch and Roll
Reaper Y Y X $ Y Y W Y pay - $60 thru version 6.99. Pretty big learning curve and way more than is needed for Librivox.
Sound Forge - Y - $ Y Y W pay - Good Windows application. Single stereo track, usually enough for LibriVox recording.
Sound Studio Y - - $ Y Y WAM Y Y pay - Costs around $80. Extremely intuitive and easy-to-use interface for recording and editing.
Total Recorder - Y - $ Y Y WM E - - - pay - Inexpensive. Standard or Pro. Plugins, including for speech recording.
Split and splice files of various formats. Evaluation copies of both versions available; pro would be better for LibriVox because of superior editing capabilities.
Twisted Wave Y - - $$ Y Y W Y Y pay - Mac Desktop $80, iPad & iPhone @ $10, and online with subscription $5 to $200.
WavePad Sound Editor Y Y Y 0/$ Y Y WAM Y - free/pay - Free demo edition that does most things. Update to full Masters edition costs around $40.

Playback

Mac Win Lin Cost Rec. Edit Playbk MP3 ID3 rip burn Notes
iTunes Y Y 0 Y Y Y Y Y free - Playback and convert files to mp3.
SongBird Y Y Y 0 Y free - Now available for both Mac and Linux.
Winamp - Y - 0$ - - Y Y Y Y both free and pay - Plays many audio and video formats; has media library manager, playlist editor, and ID3 tag editor; rip, burn, and convert between formats. Supports skins and third-party plugins.
Windows Media Player - Y - (0) - Y Y free

Others

Mac Win Lin Cost Rec. Edit Playbk MP3 ID3 rip burn Notes
Checker Y Y Y 0 - - - - Y - - free - Checks tech specs, volume, background noise, ID tags on an MP3. Uses LibriVox's standards. Ability to change ID tags.
Exact Audio Copy - Y - 0 Y Y WC E Y Y Y free - Best CD ripper. Record & edit Wave files. Convert Wave to MP3 (with LAME).
(located here because we have no experience using it to record/edit)
LAME Y Y Y 0 - - - Y - - - free - One of the two best MP3 encoders. Windows version is command-line, but mostly used with other programs.
MP3 Splt Y Y Y 0 - - - - - - - free - Splits MP3 and Ogg Vorbis files without decoding. Set split points by fixed-time length, with option to adjust split points to occur in silent gaps. Use the command-line version for batch processing of multiple files. Very fast.
MP3Gain - Y Y 0 - - - - - - - free - Measure the volume of multiple MP3 files. Do NOT use it to adjust the volume. Mac version does not measure the volume but only adjusts it.
RazorLame - Y - 0 - - - E - - - free - Graphical user interface for the LAME encoder.
Encodes one or more Wave files at a time to MP3 format. Also decodes MP3 to Wave.
Inserts same information into the ID3 tag of every MP3 file in the batch.
ReplayGain Y Y Y 0 - - - - - - - free - Audacity plug-in used to measure and adjust volume. See ReplayGain for installation and use.
WordCount Y Y Y 0 - - - - - - - free - Tool for checking word counts on Gutenberg texts. Counts each chapter separately.

Other software to edit ID3 (Windows only):

  • AudioShell - free - Integrates into Windows Explorer, you just pull up Properties and it gives you tabs for viewing and editing ID3 tags.
  • ID3 renamer - free - Rename a large number of files based on a formula. Can be used to mass rename ID3 tags as well

Misc:

  • CDex - free - A great tool for ripping CDs but also changing the sample rate for MP3s

Gord's list of freeware audio tools (including a bunch of tag editors)

These applications were recommended on Slashdot as being free of spyware/adware ... but, of course, you have to be the final judge.